How to Avoid an Unfair Dismissal Claim

29 June 2022 | Blog

We recently read about an NHS Nurse who won an unfair dismissal claim after they were sacked for being off too much. The tribunal found that the nurse suffers with migraines, depression, and anxiety which are considered disabilities. The tribunal also found evidence that her employer failed to adjust absence targets. This meant that Ms Mckenzie had no allowance for absences over and above her disability.

 

The judge came to the conclusion that part of the reason she was dismissed was due to failing to meet her attendance targets. The tribunal was in support of Mckenzie’s and ruled she was discriminated against as she was fired due to her disabilities. She also won her claim of unfair dismissal and failure to make reasonable adjustments. In addition, she will now receive compensation.

 

An employment tribunal is something you should avoid at all costs. The best way to do this is by following employment rules and supporting staff as much as possible. Special consideration also needs to take place, especially if the employee fits one of the protected characteristics of the Equality Act.

 

What is an unfair dismissal?

Unfair dismissal is when an employee’s job has been terminated, and the employer has failed to provide a fair reason. It may also be the case that the dismissal may have been fair but the employer failed to follow correct protocol.

 

Normally staff must have had two years service in order to make a tribunal claim. However, This ‘qualifying period’ does not apply to discrimination claims.

 

Unfair reasons to dismiss someone includes:

  • Request for flexible working
  • On maternity leave
  • Being pregnant
  • Requesting family leave
  • Asking for a legal right
  • Doing jury service
  • Whistleblowing
  • Plus much more

 

What is a fair dismissal?

A fair dismissal can be based on conduct, redundancy, capability or another substantial reason that justifies the termination of a contract. To ensure a dismissal was fair, It’s essential you follow the ACAS Code of Practice, your disciplinary policy, and your employment contracts are up to date. Failure in doing this can lead to a 25% boost on damages given to an unfairly dismissed employee.

 

What should I do if I’m faced with an unfair dismissal claim?

If you are faced with an unfair dismissal claim, we encourage you to contact an employment law and HR expert for advice. Disability in which causes absence is a protected characteristic within The Equality Act 2010. In addition, It’s crucial that you are clear about your reasons for the dismissal, and you are not directly or indirectly discriminating against someone.

 

If you would like any support with an unfair dismissal claim, you can contact us on 01383 668 178.

Related Topics

Drug Testing in the Workplace: Employer Do’s and Don’ts

Drug Testing in the Workplace: Employer Do’s and Don’ts

Drug testing in the workplace can be an important tool for maintaining a safe, productive, and compliant working environment. However, we understand this can be a difficult process as an employer. Implementing an effective drug testing policy requires a careful...

Closing the Gap: Addressing Workplace Inequality

Closing the Gap: Addressing Workplace Inequality

At The HR Booth, we are passionate about fostering great workplaces and encouraging employers to prioritise closing the gap. Our recent podcast featured Lindsay, Head of Policy and Development at Close the Gap, an organisation dedicated to tackling women’s inequality...

Employment Rights Bill Amendments: What you need to know

Employment Rights Bill Amendments: What you need to know

The Government proposed Employment Rights Bill amendments yesterday after consulting with trade unions and business groups. The bill was originally introduced in October 2025, and was described as being ''biggest change to workers' rights in a generation''. As an...

HR Consultant Vs Outsourced HR: Why We Are The Right Choice

HR Consultant Vs Outsourced HR: Why We Are The Right Choice

When it comes to HR support, businesses often face a critical decision: should they engage a standalone HR consultant or partner with a dedicated outsourced HR provider like The HR Booth? While standalone consultants can offer expertise, they often lack the breadth,...

Grievances at Work: Improve Culture and Reduce Complaints

Grievances at Work: Improve Culture and Reduce Complaints

In recent weeks, we have seen a significant rise in grievances at work across various industries. There doesn’t appear to be a specific trend, but one common theme is that many employees struggle to accept constructive feedback. While feedback is an essential part of...

Employer National Insurance: Everything You Need to Know

Employer National Insurance: Everything You Need to Know

With employer National Insurance increases just around the corner, now is the time for businesses to get to grips with the current rates, employment allowance, and how to effectively manage contributions. These changes can have a significant impact on payroll costs,...

Are you ready to elevate your HR strategies?

Connect with our expert team for tailored solutions and insights. Call The HR Booth at 01383 668178 or reach out via email at info@thehrbooth.co.uk or use the contact form.

Let’s transform your human resources approach together!

Privacy Preference Center